Goss Engineering -- TES Design Consulting Engineers  

  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  

 

 

TES DESIGN / THERMAL ENERGY STORAGE
ENGINEERING AT GOSS

Goss Engineering has extensive experience in the planning (including preliminary studies), design, and construction management of Thermal Energy Storage (TES) systems.

TES Overview

Completed TES System Projects

Goss Technical Articles on TES

References on Thermal Energy Storage / TES Design

Please Contact Us About Your TES Project

 

 

  

GOSS ENGINEERING 

TES DESIGN:  THERMAL ENERGY STORAGE OVERVIEW

    TES is a way of producing cooling (or heating) at one point in time and using that heat or cold at another. Common TES systems include the storage of chilled water or hot water in a tank.

    With a properly designed thermal energy storage system, Goss Engineering can help you:

    • Reduce Equipment Size (Chillers, Cooling Towers, and Pumps)
    • Reduce Overall Energy Consumption
    • Lower Energy Costs
    • Reduce Maintenance Costs

    TES systems are generally either full storage or partial storage systems. TES systems gain their major economic advantage from the difference between on-peak (daytime) and off-peak (night-time) electric energy rates and demand charges. Since electricity is the primary energy source often used for cooling, chilled water TES is more common than hot water TES (heating is generally fueled by natural gas, which is not subject to time-of-use price differentials).

    Full storage systems provide all the cooling from the TES system during a certain part of the day (generally on-peak hours) with cooling equipment shut off. During other hours, the cooling equipment is operating at higher load than required to meet the instantaneous load, with the cooling surplus stored.

    Partial storage systems typically operate chillers at a constant rate over the full day. Peak loads are met utilizing a mix of stored cooling plus instantaneous chiller produced cooling. During lighter loads, the excess capacity from the chiller is stored.

    Though full storage systems can achieve greater energy cost savings than partial storage systems, the amount of cooling equipment and TES capacity (and thus the capital cost) is generally greater with full storage systems than with a partial storage system.

   

BACK TO TOP OF PAGE

 


GOSS ENGINEERING 

C O M P L E T E D   T E S   S Y S T E M   P R O J E C T S

Date

Client

Project Title

Type of Service

Construction Budget

2009

Major Theme Park

12,000 ton-hr TES Addition SoCal

Design

$5,000,000

2009

Major Theme Park

TES Addition Feasability Study SoCal

Study

$5,000,000

2008

Major Theme Park

6,000 ton-hr TES Addition Design Hong Kong

Design

$2,500,000

2007

McKinstry

Bill and Melinda Gates 8,750 ton-hr TES Addition

Design

$6,000,000

2006

Warner Bros.

Warner Bros Studios TES Study

Study

N/A

2006

Loma Linda University

40,000 ton-hr TES Addition

Design

$7,000,000

2005

City of Hope

Central Plant/TES Expansion Study

Study

N/A

2004

LA Mission College

TES/Central Plant Design

Design (through DD)

$4,000,000

2004

LA Mission College

TES Study

Study

$4,500,000

2002

Princeton University

TES Specialist (Concept Engineer)

Design

$10,000,000

2002

Loma Linda University

TES Feasibility Study

Study

$2,000,000

2001

Univ. of Redlands

TES Study

Study

$4,000,000

1999

UC Davis

Ove ARUP TES Design

Peer Review

$10,000,000

1999

Princeton University

TES Feasibility Study

Study

N/A

1998

Cristopia

Shell Beach Florida ICE TES 

Design

N/A

1998

Cristopia

Underground ICE TES Tank-Lynwood Reg. Corr.

Design

N/A

1997

Cal Poly SLO

Thermal Energy Storage
System Study 2

Study

$3,000,000

1997

UC Riverside

Student Recreation Sports Complex Ice TES

Forensic Engineering

N/A

1996

Cal Poly SLO

Thermal Energy Storage
Study 1

Study

$1,000,000

1995

UC Irvine

TES & Central Plant
Construction Mgmt

Construction

$6,000,000

1995

County of Kern

TES Feasibility Study 

Study

$1,000,000

1994

Harrah's Las Vegas

TES Feasibility Study 

Study

N/A

1994

UC Riverside

TES Commissioning

Study

N/A

  

BACK TO TOP OF PAGE


GOSS ENGINEERING 

T E C H N I C A L   A R T I C L E S:

Goss Engineering is an active participant in the evolution of Thermal Energy Storage design practice in the United States. Goss Engineering staff members have co-authored the following articles on TES:

Commissioning Chilled Water TES Systems
from Engineered Systems Magazine, 2004

By Lucas Hyman, P.E., ASHRAE, (President, Goss Engineering)


EXCERPT:                              ( full article in PDF format       full article in web page format )

The goal of the commissioning process is to deliver a project that, at the end of construction, is fully functional and meets the owner’s needs. Some of the fundamental objectives of the commissioning process are to:

  • Clearly document the owner’s project requirements (OPR);
  • Provide documentation tools (basis of design, commissioning plan, design, and construction checklists);
  • Help with coordination between parties (owner, engineer, and contractor);
  • Accomplish ongoing verification that the engineering and construction achieve the OPR;
  • Verify that complete O&M manuals are provided to the owner;
  • Verify that maintenance personnel are properly trained; and
  • Accomplish functional performance tests that document proper operation prior to owner acceptance.

This article highlights the following:

  • Key OPR for a stratified CHW TES system;
  • Successful CHW TES design strategies (basis of design);
  • Caution flags (lessons learned);
  • Guidelines of ASHRAE Standard 150, “Method of Testing the Performance of Cool Storage Systems requirements;” and
  • Key CHW TES information to obtain during testing.

  

  full article in PDF format       full article in web page format 

  

 

  

Overcoming Low Delta T

from ASHRAE Journal, February 2004   (full article pdf )

By Lucas B. Hyman, P.E., ASHRAE, President, Goss Engineering
and Don Little, senior project manager with the Farnsworth Group, Los Angeles.

The University of California, Riverside (UCR) in Southern California is the fastest growing campus in the UC system. The campus has approximately 3 million ft2 (279 000 m2) of assignable facilities, including many science buildings with 100% outside ventilation air. Planning and modifying the campus’ chilled water system has occurred slowly, as resources were available. Unfortunately, those modifications have not always kept up with the campus’ rapid expansion.

Moreover, a lack of enforced chilled water system design standards resulted in many different building interfaces. The resulting problems with the chilled water system included unexpected low, and even negative, differential pressure (Delta P) near the end of chilled water distribution mains, and high chilled water system Delta P near the central plant. The unexpected low and negative Delta P resulted in low chilled water flow and thermal comfort complaints in buildings located at the affected ends of the distribution system. At the same time, high Delta Ps near the central plant forced open control valves, contributing to the central plant experiencing low chilled water temperature differential (Delta T). This resulted in loss of thermal energy storage (TES) capacity, increased pumping energy, and reduced available cooling capacity.

Specific causes of the chilled water problems included:

1. A mixture of constant-speed series tertiary pumps and tertiary pumps with bridge connections;

2. Secondary distribution piping constraints caused the secondary pumps to be inadequate to the task of keeping the distribution system positive;

3. Lack of variable speed drives (VSDs) on the series tertiary pumps;

4. Flow limitations through the TES system which could no longer carry the full peak load;

5. Coils selected for low Delta Ts (10°F to 12°F [5.5°C to 7°C]);

6. Some chilled water bypassing; and

7. Reverse or inoperable controls.

Thermal comfort complaints resulted primarily from a lack of chilled water flow to the buildings experience negative differential pressures. The chilled water systems for the affected buildings were not designed for negative differential pressures (i.e., the chilled water pumps did not have enough head for this condition). The design team developed a multifaceted approach to solve the problems.

Solutions included:

1. Modifying the existing chilled water distribution system to reduce system drops and system constraints;

2. Adding a central plant secondary chilled water distribution pump to increase pumping capacity;

3. Installing, at buildings near the central plant, modulating two-way pressure independent control valves (PICVs) to improve controllability at high Delta Ps and to help prevent chilled water bypassing via forced open control valves;

4. Converting from a full storage TES operational strategy to a partial storage strategy; and

5. Stopping short circuits (bypass of chilled water supply to return), correcting reverse logic on some control valves, and addressing other control deficiencies.

VFDs were not added to tertiary pumps because the campus limited the scope of any actual building chilled water system work. After the modifications were completed, the UCR chilled water distribution system achieved a positive Delta P at the end of the piping mains, achieved cooling thermal comfort in previous problem buildings, and attained a 20°F (11°C) Delta T in the chilled water and TES system.

full article pdf
  

   

   

BACK TO TOP OF PAGE

 


REFERENCES ON TES / THERMAL ENERGY STORAGE
from industry, university and government sources

 

Thermal Energy Storage for Space Cooling:
Technology for reducing on-peak electricity demand and cost [includes TES design and applications]
U.S. Department of Energy  --  Federal Energy Management Program -- December 2000 -- 36 pages

    [Excerpt]   Thermal energy storage for space cooling, also known as cool storage, chill storage, or cool thermal storage, is a relatively mature technology that continues to improve through evolutionary design advances. Cool storage technology can be used to significantly reduce energy costs by allowing energy-intensive, electrically driven cooling equipment to be predominantly operated during off-peak hours when electricity rates are lower. In addition, some system configurations result in lower first costs and/or lower operating costs compared to non-storage systems.     more

Energy Storage: A Critical Path to Sustainability
Mark M. MacCracken, PE, LEED AP, President, CALMAC [manufacturer of thermal storage equipment]

    [Excerpt]   To understand the importance of storage, it is imperative that one understands the electric power grid. If you have ever lived in a warm environment, you have probably experienced a brown out. Brown outs typically happen in the heat of day, when the temperatures are high and buildings across the area are turning up the air-conditioning and creating an enormous need for energy. Because of this, in the middle of any day, the demand on the power grid is the highest. In addition to the air-conditioning running at full power, more lights are on and multiple appliances are in use. Because of the strain on the grid, the costs for electricity are highest during those “on-peak” hours and the generation is often the dirtiest since all the old plants are turned on to help meet the demand. On the flip side—at night—when the majority of people are sleeping, there is a very low demand on the grid, and sometimes, even over-capacity. This is called “off-peak.”

    Storage is the Answer:  In its present configuration, our electric grid has almost no “storage” capability so that electricity must be produced exactly when it is needed. This is possible when your source of energy is fossil fuel (stored energy) but is very difficult and expensive when it is renewable energy (wind or solar). Adding energy storage to the grid will be critical in our quest to lower societies’ carbon emissions.     more

Thermal Energy Storage Myths, by Mark M. MacCracken, P.E., offers systematic data to refute popular misconceptions about TES (too big, too complicated, too expensive, etc).  From ASHRAE Journal.

Thermal Energy Storage at a Federal Facility
The Dallas Veterans Administration Medical Center and Texas Utilities Electric Company
join in an unprecedented partnership to lower energy costs.
U.S. Department of Energy  --  Federal Energy Management Program -- July 2000 -- 2 pages 

2009 Energy Storage Research Portfolio from the Electric Power Research Institute

Catalog of Articles and Presentations on TES design and applications from the  Energy Storage Council

Source Energy and Environmental Impacts of Thermal Energy Storage  -- a 1996 report from the
California Energy Commission Thermal Energy Storage Systems Collaborative 

Thermal Energy Storage: Systems and Applications
by Ibrahim Dincer and Marc A. Rosen  (Wiley Engineering Textbook, 2002)

    [Book description from Amazon]   During the last two decades many research and development activities related to energy have concentrated on efficient energy use and energy savings and conservation. In this regard, Thermal Energy Storage (TES) systems can play an important role, as they provide great potential for facilitating energy savings and reducing environmental impact. Thermal storage has received increasing interest in recent years in terms of its applications, and the enormous potential it offers both for more effective use of thermal equipment and for economic, large-scale energy substitutions. Indeed, TES appears to provide one of the most advantageous solutions for correcting the mismatch that often occurs between the supply and demand of energy. Despite this increase in attention, no book is currently available which comprehensively covers TES.

    Presenting contributions from prominent researchers and scientists, this book is primarily concerned with TES systems and their applications. It begins with a brief summary of general aspects of thermodynamics, fluid mechanics and heat transfer, and then goes on to discuss energy storage technologies, environmental aspects of TES, energy and exergy analyses, and practical applications. Furthermore, this book provides coverage of the theoretical, experimental and numerical techniques employed in the field of thermal storage. Numerous case studies and illustrative examples are included throughout.

    Some of the unique features of this book include:

    • State-of-the art descriptions of many facets of TES systems and applications
    • In-depth coverage of exergy analysis and thermodynamic optimization of TES systems
    • Extensive new material on TES technologies, including advances due to innovations in sensible- and latent-energy storage
    • Key chapters on environmental issues, sustainable development and energy savings
    • Extensive coverage of practical aspects of the design, evaluation, selection and implementation of TES systems
    • Wide coverage of TES-system modelling, ranging in level from elementary to advanced
    • Abundant design examples, case studies and references

    In short, this book forms a valuable reference resource for practicing engineers and researchers, and a research-oriented text book for advanced undergraduate and graduate students of various engineering disciplines. Instructors will find that its breadth and structure make it an ideal core text for TES and related courses.   more

Thermal Energy Storage for Sustainable Energy Consumption: Fundamentals, Case Studies and Design
NATO Science Series II: Mathematics, Physics and Chemistry (Springer, 2007)

    [Book description from Amazon]   We all share a small planet. Our growing thirst for energy already threatens the future of our earth. Fossil fuels – energy resources of today – are not evenly distributed on the earth. 10% of the world’s population exploits 90% of its resources. Today’s energy systems rely heavily on fossil fuel resources which are diminishing ever faster.  The world must prepare for a future without fossil fuels.

    Thermal energy storage provides us with a flexible heating and/or cooling tool to combat climate change through conserving energy and increasing energy while utilizing natural renewable energy resources.  Thermal storage applications have been proven to be efficient and financially viable, yet they have not been exploited sufficiently.

    Çukurova University, Turkey in collaboration with Ljubljana University, Slovenia and the International Energy Agency Implementing Agreement on Energy Conservation Through Energy Storage (IEA ECES IA) has organized this NATO Advanced Study Institute on Thermal Energy Storage for Sustainable Energy Consumption – Fundamentals, Case Studies and Design (NATO ASI TESSEC), in Cesme, Izmir, Turkey on June 6-17, 2005.

    Eminent experts who have worked in a number of Annexes of IEA ECES IA were among the lecturers of this Advanced Study Institute. 24 lecturers from Canada, Germany, Japan, The Netherlands, Slovenia, Spain, Sweden, Turkey, and USA have all enthusiastically contributed to the scientific programme. In Çesme, Turkey, 65 students from 17 countries participated in this 2 week summer school.

    This book contains the manuscripts prepared based on the lectures included in the scientific programme of the NATO ASI TESSEC. You can also find the design example assignments from the computer workshops.    more

   

BACK TO TOP OF PAGE